Film Or Digital at Photo School?
School Photography Stuck in the Past With Film
Recent talk about the need to buy a 35mm film SLR as a first camera as being essential to properly learn the basics of photography seems misguided.
Apparently, some school photography programs still insist on perpetuating the archaic practice of film phootography. It seems very strange, when a Digital SLR offers much more as a learning tool than any film camera. Many photographers find a dramatic improvement in their knowledge following the move into the 21st century and their first DSLR, retiring their film bodies to the cupboard. What makes the digital camera such a good learning tool?
Instant Results
As soon as photographers make the image, they can quickly review it on the DSLR’s LCD screen; make subtle exposure settings or compositional changes and then shoot again. With film, there is a long drawn-out process of developing the film, and printing the images, before seeing the results.
Comprehensive Information
A feature of digital cameras is that they store all the camera's settings for each shot in the same file as the image data. Photographers can view the information on the LCD screen as part of the review process, or later on when displaying the images on the computer. This means for every shot the details of aperture, shutter speed, ISO, focal length and more are available. With older lenses not all the information is recorded so modern lenses on DSLR are a help in the initial learning phase. This replaces the tedious option of writing all the relevant data in a notebook after each shot, and then trying to work out which entries corresponded to which image. A one-stop change in shutter speed or aperture between two other wise identical images is now recorded on the digital file for close examination and comparison on the computer.
Disposable Not Pointless
There is criticism that the low cost per shot of digital cameras encourages thoughtless clicking in the hope of some images turning out properly, it does not have to be this way. This is more a fault of lazy photographers rather than their tools. It is a boon for photography students to quickly take shots, and then delete them, without incurring the time and financial penalties of film processing and printing. It encourages students to practice and experiment with their camera.
The instantaneous nature of digital photography means a student can take series of shots, and immediately analyze them. With the lessons learnt, the student can take more shots of the same location and apply a new strategy. What can be accomplished in minutes with a digital camera could take days or longer with a film camera.
Under The Microscope
Large screen computer monitors and editing software allow expanded views of digital images, providing photography students with a close view of their images. This close inspection reveals some of the subtle differences, especially with the advent of larger wide screen LCD computer monitors enabling photographers to have enlarged views of their images.
For Example
The article on metering patterns features a series of photographs of with the same subject and lighting conditions, and altering only one camera setting. This clearly illustrates the differences resulting from using the camera settings, demonstrating to any student the characteristics of each metering system.
